GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE & INDUSTRY
(DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE)
NOTIFICATION
PRELIMINARY FINDINGS
New Delhi, the 1st February, 2002
Subject:- Anti-dumping investigation concerning
imports of Sodium Nitrite from European Union (EU) and Taiwan Preliminary Findings.
No.54/1/2001-DGAD. - The Government of India having regard to the Customs
Tariff Act, 1975 as amended in 1995 and the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and
Collection of Anti-dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules,
1995, thereof:
A. PROCEDURE:
1. The procedure described below has been followed with regard to the investigations:
(ix) The Delegation of EU in India and Taiwan Cultural Center, New Delhi was informed about the initiation of the investigations in accordance with rule 6(2) with a request to advise the exporters/producers from their country to respond to the questionnaire with in the prescribed time. A copy of the letter, petition and questionnaire sent to the exporters was also sent to them, alongwith the list of known exporters and producer from European Union and Taiwan.
(x) The questionnaire was also sent to the following importers of Sodium Nitrite in India calling for necessary information in accordance with rule 6(4);
(xi) Additional information regarding injury was sought from the petitioner, which was also received;
(xii) The Authority made available non-confidential version of the evidence presented by various interested parties in the form of a public file kept open for inspection by the interested parties;
(xiii) The Authority sought and verified information deemed necessary for the investigation, and the investigations were carried out at the premises of Petitioners ;
(xiv) The Authority also conducted cost investigation and worked out optimum cost of production and cost to make and sell in India on the basis of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.
(xv) The investigations covered the period of 1st April, 2000 to 31st March, 2001 (12 months);
(xvi) **** in this notification represents information furnished by an interested party on confidential basis and so considered by the Authority under the Rules;
B Petitioners Views:
2. The petitioner has raised following issues in their petition :
C. ON CUMULATIVE ASSESSMENT:
3. The exporters from Taiwan and European union are dumping Sodium Nitrite in the Indian market. Annexure II (iii) to the Anti Dumping Rules provide that in case imports of a product from more than one country are being simultaneously subjected to anti dumping investigations, the designated authority will cumulatively assess the effect of such imports, in case it determines that:
4. ON OTHER ISSUES:
Imports from subject countries increased significantly in absolute terms. As a direct consequence, the Indian industry lost sales to such an extent resulting in lower capacity utilisation of domestic industry.
D.Views of Exporters, Importers and other interested parties:
5. M/S BASF, AKTIENSELLSHAFT, GERMANY:
(a) They have stated that they have decided not to fill in the questionnaire concerning dumping and have opinioned that it is evident that due to the 41.3% regular duty there has to be dumping;
(b) The exporter has pointed out that the Taiwanese exporter quoted in the petition by Domestic industry is M/s Chinfong Taipei, is not the producer of the product under investigation and to their knowledge the company in Taiwan, imports the product from M/s Deepak;
6. M/S TERRA NITROGEN (UK) LIMITED, STOCKTON-ON-TEES TS17 6PT :
The exporter has stated that they did not export Sodium Nitrite into India during the period of investigation and thus they have no comments to offer.
E. EXAMINATION OF ISSUES RAISED:
7. The submissions made by the exporters, importers petitioners and other interested parties have been examined, considered and have been dealt with at appropriate places therein.
F. Product under consideration:
8. The product under consideration in the petition is Sodium Nitrite originating in or exported from EU and Taiwan. The product is classified under Customs Tariff heading 2834.10. The classification is, however, indicative only and in no way binding on the present investigations. The petitioner has stated that the product is under OGL category as per the import policy and is an oxidizing as also a reducing agent. It is a white crystal powder mostly used in pharmaceutical industries, dye industry, lubricants, construction chemicals, meat processing, textiles etc.
G. LIKE ARTICLE:
9. Definition of Like Article states as under:
H. DOMESTIC INDUSTRY:
10. (a) The petition has been filed by M/s. Deepak Nitrite Ltd., Baroda on behalf of domestic industry. There are three other producers, i.e. M/s. Punjab Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals Ltd., M/s. National Fertilizers Ltd. and Rashtriya Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd. who have created capacities for production of Sodium Nitrite in the country. The petitioner accounts for around 64% of production of domestic industry during the period of investigation.
(b) In light of the foregoing, the Authority concludes that the petitioner has the standing to file the petition on behalf of the domestic industry under the rules.
I. DUMPING:
11. Under Section 9A (1)(c), normal value in relation to an article means:
Provided that in the case of import of the article from a country other than the country of origin and where the article has been merely transshipped through the country of export or such article is not produced in the country of export or there is no comparable price in the country of export, the normal value shall be determined with reference to its price in the country or origin".
J. DUMPING AND DUMPING MARGIN:
12. M/S BASF, AKTIENGENSELLSCHAFT, GERMANY:
13. M/S TERRA NITROGEN (UK) LIMITED, STOCKTON-ON-TEES TS17 6PT :
The exporter has stated that they did not export Sodium Nitrite into India during the period of investigation and thus they have no comments to offer.
No other exporter from EU or Taiwan have responded to this investigation.
NORMAL VALUE:
The petitioner has claimed normal value in Europe on the basis of the prices at which Sodium Nitrite has been exported to third countries (Czech Republic). The claim has been supplemented with the estimates of cost of production. The normal value claimed is US $ **** per MT on the basis of export price to third countries. The Authority has assessed normal value at US $ **** /MT on the basis of estimates of cost of production which is lower than the export price to third countries.
It is also claimed that the petitioner is also exporting the subject product to the European Union. The prices at which the petitioner is exporting the subject goods to European Union are much higher than the prices at which the exporters from European Union are exporting the subject product to India. Thus, even considering the petitioners own export price to European Union, there would be dumping of the subject goods by the exporters from the European Union.
Normal value in case of Taiwan has been claimed on the basis of the estimates of cost of production. The same is assessed at US $ ****/MT.
EXPORT PRICE:
The petitioner has claimed export price based on the data published by the DGCI&S, Calcutta. The export price comes to US $ ****PMT and US$ ****PMT in case of European Union and Taiwan respectively. Adjustments have been claimed from the export price on account of Ocean Freight:, Marine insurance, Commission, Inland Transportation and Port handling and port charges.
The Rules relating to comparison provides comparison of normal value and export price provides as follows:
"While arriving at margin of dumping Designated Authority shall make a fair comparison between the export price and the normal value. A comparison shall be made at the same level of trade, normally at ex-works level and in respect of sales made and as nearly possible the same time. Due allowance shall be made in each case on its merits, for differences which occur price comparability including differences in conditions and terms and sales, taxation, levels of trade quantities, physical characteristics and any other differences which are demonstrated to affect price comparability".
15. For the purpose of fair comparison between normal value and export price the Authority took into account the information furnished by the petitioner and other published information available with the Authority.
The dumping margin comes as under:
US $ per MT |
European Union |
Chinese Taipei |
Normal value |
**** |
**** |
Export price |
**** |
**** |
Dumping margin |
**** |
**** |
Dumping margin % of EP |
71.37% |
102.98% |
K. INJURY & CAUSAL LINK :
16. (a) Under Rule 11 supra, Annexure-II, When a finding of injury is arrived at, such finding shall involve determination of the injury to the domestic industry, " taking into account all relevant facts, including the volume of dumped imports, their effect on prices in the domestic market for like articles and the consequent effect of such imports on domestic producers of such articles ." In considering the effect of the dumped imports on prices, it is considered necessary to examine whether there has been a significant price undercutting by the dumped imports as compared with the price of the like article in India, or whether the effect of such imports is otherwise to depress prices to a significant degree or prevent price increases, which otherwise would have occurred, to a significant degree;
(b) Rule (iii) of the Annexure II to the Rules requires that in case imports of a product from more than one country are being simultaneously subjected to anti-dumping investigation, The Authority will cumulatively assess the effect of such imports. Such assessment can be, however, made only if it is determined that:
17. The Authority notes that the margin of dumping and quantum of imports from subject country are more than the limits prescribed above. Cumulative assessment of the effects of imports is appropriate since the export prices from the subject country were directly competing with the prices offered by the domestic industry in the Indian market.
18. For the examination of the impact of imports on the domestic industry in India, the Authority has considered such further indices having a bearing on the state of the industry such as quantum of Imports production, capacity utilisation, sales quantum, stock, market share, profitability, net sales realisation, the magnitude and margin of dumping etc. in accordance with Annexure II (iv) of the rules supra.
(a) IMPORTS AND MARKET SHARE:
Imports from subject countries and other countries in India as also their share in terms of total imports in India as well as demand of sodium nitrite in India are shown below.
All figures are in MT |
1997-98 | 1998-99 | 1999-00 | 2000-01 |
European Union(EU) |
525 | 520 | 692 | 638 |
Taiwan |
160 | 0 | 372 | 676 |
Total subject countries |
685 | 520 | 1064 | 1314 |
Other countries |
||||
China |
3095 | 2144 | 3422 | 1539 |
Others |
145 | 229 | 2 | 67 |
Total imports in to the country |
3925 | 2893 | 4488 | 2920 |
Sale of domestic industry |
14231 | 13978 | 16456 | 14996 |
Sales of other producers |
7919 | 7465 | 7440 | 8323 |
Demand in the country |
26075 | 24336 | 28384 | 26239 |
Share of subject countries in total imports (%) |
||||
EU |
13.38 |
17.97 |
15.42 |
21.85 |
Taiwan |
4.08 |
0.00 |
8.29 |
23.15 |
Subject Countries |
17.45 |
17.97 |
23.71 |
45.00 |
Market share in Demand |
||||
EU |
2.01 |
2.14 |
2.44 |
2.43 |
Taiwan |
0.61 |
0.00 |
1.31 |
2.58 |
Subject Countries |
2.63 |
2.14 |
3.75 |
5.01 |
Other Countries |
12.43 |
9.75 |
12.06 |
6.12 |
Domestic industry |
54.58 |
57.44 |
57.98 |
57.15 |
Other Domestic Producers |
30.37 |
30.67 |
26.21 |
31.72 |
Total All Countries |
100.00 |
100.00 |
100.00 |
100.00 |
The Authority notes that:-
(b) DECLINE IN EXPORT PRICE:
Export prices from the subject countries have declined significantly, as is evident from the table below:
| Year | Export price Rs./Kg |
Export price US $/kg. |
1997-98 |
**** |
**** |
1998-99 |
**** |
**** |
1999-00 |
**** |
**** |
2000-01 |
**** |
**** |
The Authority notes that the decline in the export price in terms of US $ is more significant than the decline in terms of Indian Rupee. The decline in export price has directly resulted in decline in landed value of the imported material as is evident from the table below.
Year |
Landed price Rs./ Kg.* |
1997-98 |
**** |
1998-99 |
**** |
1999-00 |
**** |
2000-01 |
**** |
Evidently, the export price from the subject countries have declined, except in the year 1999-00, resulting in decline in landed price of imported material, forcing the domestic industry to keep their selling price significantly below than the fair selling price of the domestic industry, which should have been increased after imposition of Anti Dumping against dumped imports from China.
(c) PRODUCTION, SALES AND CAPACITY UTILIZATION:
Production, sales and capacity utilization of the petitioner with respect to Sodium Nitrite/Nitrate (as capacity of 27000 MT includes nitrite and nitrate) has been as under:
In MT |
Capacity @ |
Production @ |
Capacity Utilisation(%) |
Sales Volume |
1997-98 |
27,000 |
24425 |
90.46 |
**** |
1998-99 |
27,000 |
24325 |
90.09 |
**** |
1999-00 |
27,000 |
27964 |
103.57 |
**** |
2000-01 |
27,000 |
26429 |
97.89 |
**** |
Note: @ Includes Sodium Nitrite and Nitrate capacity
It is evident from the above, production, sales and capacity utilization of the domestic industry increased upto 1999-00. However, all the three parameters have declined in 2000-01. The domestic industry should have increased sales volumes and hence production and capacity utilization in 2000-01 after imposition of Anti Dumping Duty on imports from China. However, the dumping from Taiwan and EU prevented the domestic industry from increasing its sales and hence production and capacity utilization.
(d) SELLING PRICE:
The net sales realization of the Petitioners with respect to Sodium Nitrite are given in the table given below.
Period |
Net sales realization (Rs. Per MT.) |
1997-98 |
**** |
1998-99 |
**** |
1999-00 |
**** |
2000-01 |
**** |
Sales realization of the domestic industry declined significantly in 1999-00. The increase in the sales realization in 2000-01 is due to steep increase in the cost of production. Sales realization is required to be seen along with the cost of production of the domestic industry. Cost of production of the domestic industry increased in 2000-01, whereas the domestic industry was unable to increase the selling prices proportionately. The imports have thus prevented the domestic industry from effecting legitimate price increases.
It is also relevant to point out that the domestic industry should have increased prices much more than the increase in 1999-00. The NIP fixed by the Designated Authority in the previous investigations was US $****. Thus, the domestic industry is suffering severe price depression/suppression in the market. Also relevant to note that the export price from the subject countries declined continually, except in 1999-2000, resulting in decline in the landed price of imports. In 1999-2000, the increase in the sales volume of the domestic industry and increase in export price from subject countries have to be seen together. Decline in the export price from the subject countries forced the domestic industry to sell even below the cost of production.
(e) PROFITABILITY:
The selling prices of the domestic industry remained unremunerative in spite of imposition of Anti Dumping Duty on imports from China. Dumping from China coupled with fresh dumping from the subject countries has resulted in wiping out of profits of the petitioner. Profit/loss of the domestic industry have been as under:-
Rs./MT |
Cost of production |
Selling Price |
Profit/Loss |
1998-99 |
**** |
**** |
**** |
1999-00 |
**** |
**** |
**** |
2000-01 |
**** |
**** |
**** |
19. CONCLUSION:
The Authority thus observe that:
L. CAUSAL LINK:
20. IMPORTS FROM OTHER COUNTRIES:
The imports are primarily from China, European Union and Taiwan. Against China, Anti Dumping Duty is already in force. Imports from other countries are de-minimus. The prices from other countries are higher. Imports from other countries are, therefore, not causing injury to the domestic industry. Imports of Sodium Nitrite in India as per DGCI&S are as under:
Country |
Qty/Kg | Share % | |
Subject countries |
|||
Taiwan |
675580 |
23.14 |
|
European Union |
637716 |
21.84 |
|
Countries attracting duties |
|||
China |
1539742 |
52.72 |
|
Other Countries |
|||
Singapore |
3000 |
0.10 |
|
USA |
64282 |
2.20 |
|
Total |
2462446 |
100.00 |
|
21. DEMAND & OTHER FACTORS:
M. INDIAN INDUSTRYS INTEREST AND OTHER ISSUES:
22. The purpose of anti dumping duties, in general, is to eliminate dumping which is in general interest of the country. It is recognised that the imposition of anti dumping duties might affect the price levels of the products manufactured using the subject goods and consequently might have some influence on relative competitiveness of these products. However, fair competition on the Indian market will not be reduced by the anti dumping measures, particularly if the levy of the anti dumping duty is restricted to an amount necessary to redress the injury to the domestic industry. On the contrary, imposition of anti dumping measures would remove the unfair advantages gained by dumping practices, would prevent the decline of the domestic industry and help maintain availability of wider choice to the consumers of sodium nitrite. Imposition of anti dumping measures would not restrict imports from the subject countries in any way, and therefore, would not affect the availability of the product to the consumers.
23. To ascertain the extent of anti-dumping duty necessary to remove the injury to the domestic industry, the Authority relied upon reasonable selling prices of Sodium Nitrite in India for the domestic industry, by considering the optimum cost of production at optimum level of capacity utilisation for the domestic industry.
N. LANDED VALUE:
24. The landed value of imports from EU & Taiwan have been determined on the basis of weighted average export price of Sodium Nitrite from EU & Taiwan, after adding the prevailing level of customs duties and one percent landing charges.
O. CONCLUSIONS;
25. The Authority, after considering the foregoing, concludes that:
26 Authority considered to recommend the amount of anti-dumping duty equal to the margin of dumping or less, which if levied, would remove the injury to the domestic industry, and the date of commencement of such duty (clause (d) Rule 4 supra as amended).
27. Accordingly, the Authority recommends provisional Anti-dumping Duty on Sodium Nitrite from subject countries. The Anti-dumping Duty shall be the amount mentioned in column (3) below , from the date of notification to be issued in this regard by the Central Government, on all imports of Sodium Nitrite originating in or exported from Territory of European Union and Taiwan falling under Chapter28 of the Customs Tariff, pending final determination.
Country / Territory |
Exporters |
Amount US $ /MT |
(1) |
(2) |
(3) |
Territory of European Union |
All Exporters |
51.83 |
Taiwan |
All Exporters |
107.85 |
28. Landed value of imports for the purpose shall be the assessable value as determined by the customs under the Customs Act, 1962 and all duties of customs except duties levied under Section 3, 3A,8B and 9, 9A of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975.
P. FURTHER PROCEDURE:
(LV Saptharishi)
Designated Authority